History of Brewsters Italian Café

Opened in 1992, Brewster’s has enjoyed many years as Harbor Country’s most popular Italian café by locals and visitors alike. Our award winning wood-fired pizza along with our homemade pasta dishes made us famous, but superior service and a beautiful atmosphere is what keeps our guests coming back. Located in the heart of downtown New Buffalo, Michigan, our outdoor dining patio is nestled in a beautiful garden, complete with a fountain!

Brewster’s is truly the place for all occasions. Be it sipping cappuccinos in the morning; enjoying a glass of wine by the fire; or savoring a spectacular dinner alfresco, you will feel like you have found your special place. We are in the heart of Harbor Country, but you will feel like you have taken a stroll through Italy.

Mangiare Bene! Eat Well!