CATERING MENU

In order to best accommodate your needs, we usually require a 48-hr. notice for all catering orders. We’re able to do many of our items within a 24 hr. hour time frame, but it’s best to give us at least 48 hours so that we’ve got enough ordering and prep time. Contact (269) 469-3005 or email brewstersnewbuffalo@gmail.com to order.

Salad and Antipasti

Small Serves 10-15
Large Serves 20-25

Brewster’s Salad

Small $30 – Large $55
Mixed Greens, House Cheese, Croutons and our Balsamic Herb Dressing

Brewster’s Chicken or Tuna Salad

Small $45 – Large $65
Our Homemade Classic Salads served over Mixed Greens

Pasta Salad

Small $35 – Large $60
Artichokes, Olives, Salami, Onion, Peppers & Cheeses tossed with Pasta of the Day in a Flavorful Homemade Dressing

Queen Margherita

Small $35 – Large $65
Fresh Mozzarella, Roma Tomatoes with Pine Nuts, Fresh Basil and Reggiano drizzled with Extra Virgin Olive Oil and served with Balsamic Vinegar.

Chopped Margherita Salad

Small $45 – Large $65                                                                                                           Chopped Lettuce, Tomatoes, Fresh Mozzarella, Olives & Red Onions topped with Basil, Reggiano, Pine Nuts & Balsamic Reduction

Baked Spinach Asiago Artichoke Dip

Small $40 Large $70
Served with our Rustic Flatbread from our Wood-Fired Oven

Brewster’s Charcuterie Board

Small $55 – Large $95
An assortment of Salamis, Cheeses, Olives, Cipollini Onions & Peppadews

Bruschetta

Small $25 – Large $50

Sandwich Tray

$8 per Sandwich (please note, a five (5) sandwich minimum is required)
Assortment of turkey, roast beef, chicken salad & caprese sandwiches

 

Pastas

Small Serves 10-15
Large Serves 15-25

Tortellini Roma

Small $50 – Large $85
Tri Color Cheese Tortellini with Roma Tomatoes, Fresh Basil, and garlic tossed in Extra Virgin Olive Oil and sprinkled with Parmigiano

Manicotti

Small $30 – Large $45 | Add Chicken: Small $45 – Large $75

Spinach and Ricotta-filled Manicotti with Marinara

Pasta Verano

Small $45 – Large $75 | add Chicken – Small $60 – Large $100
Sautéed Fresh Vegetables tossed with Pasta in our house made Genovese Style Pesto Sauce and sprinkled with Freshly Grated Parmesan

Pasta Marinara

Small $30 – Large $45 | add Meatballs – Small $45 – Large $70
Our Famous Marinara slow simmered for hours and tossed with Pasta of the Day. Topped with cheese and baked.

Chicken Asiago

Small $60 – Large $100
Sautéed Chicken Breast, Broccoli Florets & Sun Dried Tomatoes tossed in a flavorful Asiago Cream Sauce over Pasta.

Chicken Parmesan

Small $60 – Large $90
Parmesan Bread Crumb-crusted Chicken breast with melted Mozzarella and Marinara over Chef’s Choice of Pasta

Beef Tenderloin Tips Marsala

Small $65 – Large $105
Pan Seared Beef Tenderloin Tips, Button Mushrooms and Baby Spinach simmered in a Classic Marsala Sauce tossed with Pasta

Lasagna

Small $50 – Large $80
Our House Specialty! Layers of Ricotta, Cheeses, Italian Sausage, Marinara, Garlic and Pasta Sheets

Pasta Bolognese

Small $50 – Large $80
A Classic Italian Ragu of Ground Pork & Tomato Herb Sauce over Pasta of the Day

Sausage & Peppers Pasta

Small $60 – Large $100

Sausage & Peppers in our House Made Marinara over Pastta

Desserts

Cookie Tray

Chocolate Chunk, Peanut Butter, Apple Caramel Oatmeal and Lemon Blueberry $2/each – Royale $2.25/each

Tiramisu

Our version of the Classic! – Small $65 – Large $100

Bakery & Dessert Selections are always changing, so let us tell you what is currently available! 

House Specialties

House Cheese – $15 per pound

House Dressing – Pint $8 – Quart $16

Pizza Dough – $3 per dough ball ($4 for sourdough)

House Bread – Loaf $8