Starting Monday, January 15th, we will be temporarily closed for renovations and will be back next month by Valentine’s Day. We’ll keep you updated as we go! If you need to get in contact with us, the best way is via email: brewstersnewbuffalo@gmail.com

See you in February!!


Summer Hours:

11:30 - 10 Sun. - Thurs.

11:30 - 11 Fri. - Sat.

Winter Hours:

11:30 - 9 Sun. - Thurs.

11:30 - 10 Fri. - Sat.

Authentic Italian

About Us

Brewster’s Italian Café, located in downtown New Buffalo, Michigan in the heart of Harbor Country, recreates a quaint Italian street café. Cooking with a wide variety of fresh and locally-sourced ingredients, Brewster’s focuses on creating high quality dishes from the many regions of Italy. The menu changes every meal, every day but always features a wide variety of anti pasta, salads, wood-fired pizza, amazing pasta and a fresh assortment of meats, fish and seafood. Sandwiches, pasta, pizza and Stromboli are available during lunch. Brewster’s bakery is open everyday, and offers homemade desserts, cookies and pastries with espresso and coffee. Join us for lunch or dinner in the beautiful outdoor garden or next to the fireplace in the atrium bar. A private room is available for parties as well as full catering services. Children are welcome with a menu just for them.